Godechot Olivier, 2014, The Chance of Influence. A Natural Experiment on the Role of Social Capital in Academic Hiring, maxpo discussion paper, n°14/1.
The effect of social capital is often overrated because contacts and centrality can be a consequence of success rather than its cause. Randomized or natural experiments are an excellent way to assess the real causal effect of social capital, but these are rare. This paper relies on data from one such experiment: recruitment at the EHESS, a leading social science institution in France, between 1960 and 2005. The EHESS recruitment process uses an electoral commission to produce a first-stage ranking of applicants, which is then provided to the faculty assembly for final voting. The commission is partly composed of faculty members drawn at random, a feature that this article exploits in order to compare the chances for success of applicants whose contacts have been drawn to sit on the commission (treated) versus those whose contacts have not been drawn (control). It shows that a contact such as a PhD advisor has a causal impact, especially for assistant professor hiring exams: it doubles the chance of being ranked and increases the share of votes by 10 percent. This phenomenon may explain part of the classic “academic inbreeding” issue.
Français | English
OgO: plus ici|more here
[Encadrement] Montagne, Sabine. 2017. Investir pour autrui aux États-Unis. 1950-2000, Habilitation à diriger des recherches, Université de Saint Quentin en Yvelines ...: plus ici|more here
[Encadrement] Benhmarhnia, Sarah. 2017. Les inégalités d’exposition aux pollutions. L’emplacement des incinérateurs de déchets en France: l’importance de l’échelle de ...: plus ici|more here
[Encadrement] Clemessy, Timothée. 2017. “A brand new capital ?” L’impact des opérations de fusion et acquisition sur le nantissement des ...: plus ici|more here
[Publications] Godechot (Olivier), Introduction: Is sociology of finance a general sociology?, Finance at work: plus ici|more here
[Publications] Tomaskovic-Devey (Donald) (with) Godechot (Olivier et al.), The Comparative Organizational Inequality Network: Toward an Economic Sociology of Inequality, economic sociology: plus ici|more here
[Publications] Godechot (Olivier), Inequality: A Piketty et al. Moment in the Social Sciences, economic sociology_the european electronic newsletter: plus ici|more here
HOP ! [V. 0.93]
clics / mois.